Archiver > GENEALOGY-DNA > 2010-11 > 1289871928

Subject: Re: [DNA] GAP 2.0 - project join requests
Date: Mon, 15 Nov 2010 17:45:28 -0800 (PST)
In-Reply-To: <>

An update - the "old GAP" join requests included the participant's e-mail address, so I contacted them to send in another request to join the project.  That seemed to work as the join requests now show up in the new GAP 2.0 and I have been able to approve the requests.   So, it appears that the join requests got lost in the process of changing over to the new GAP.

The new join request e-mails do not include the e-mail address of the individual trying to join the project.  So, there is now no way to contact an individual directly until they actually join the project. 

Rebecca Christensen

--- On Mon, 11/15/10, John Chandler <> wrote:
From: John Chandler <>
Subject: Re: [DNA] GAP 2.0 - project join requests
Date: Monday, November 15, 2010, 1:29 PM

Rebecca wrote:
> Anyone else having problems finding people in Gap 2.0 who are trying
> to join the project?  I received 2 e-mails that people who tested
> through NG want to join the project, but they are no where to be
> found.  Gap 2.0 indicates that no one is waiting to join the project. 

Yes, I've had the same problem.  The beta version of GAP 2 had a
stub for Join Requests that said "must use old GAP during test
period", but there is nothing in the "production" version for
this operation.  Indeed, the Join Authorization facility itself
was not included in the beta version, and it turns out to be
fatally flawed, too.  It wants to be an omnipotent Request
Management System, and so it hides the contact info for the
requestor from the administrators, allowing only a "click to
reply" option.  I thought we had quashed that idea when it
surfaced once before, but the thirst for control seems endless.

                    John Chandler

This thread: